Is It Haram to Buy or Sell Cats in Islam?

Is It Haram to Buy or Sell Cats in Islam?

Question

Salam alaikum.

What is the evidence that it is permissible to buy a cat as a pet? I heard that buying and selling cats is haram in Islam. Is there a hadith about this?

Answer

Alhamdulillah, wassalatu wassalamu ala rasulillah, wa ala alihi wa sahbihi ajma’in.

Yes, there is an authentic hadith concerning the prohibition of selling cats. However, the scholars differed regarding its interpretation and application.

The majority of jurists, including the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, and Hanbali schools, permit buying and selling domesticated cats that provide a lawful benefit.

Other scholars understood the hadith more literally and prohibited selling cats, even when they are domesticated.

Therefore, the issue is one of recognized scholarly disagreement, and it would be incorrect to claim that all scholars unanimously prohibited buying and selling cats.

1. The Hadith Concerning the Sale of Cats

Jabir ibn Abdullah reported:

“The Messenger of Allah ﷺ prohibited the price of dogs and cats.” Sahih Muslim

The Arabic wording includes:

زجر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم عن ثمن الكلب والسنور

This narration is authentic and forms the primary evidence for scholars who prohibit selling cats.

The word sinnawr refers to a cat.

However, the scholars differed regarding whether this prohibition applies to all cats or whether it concerns particular circumstances, such as wild cats that cannot be kept or benefit their owners.

This difference in interpreting the hadith explains why the majority of jurists permitted the sale of domesticated cats despite the narration.

2. Is Keeping a Cat as a Pet Permissible?

Keeping a cat as a pet is permissible, provided it is treated humanely and given appropriate food, water, shelter, and care.

The Prophet ﷺ said concerning cats:

“They are not impure. They are among those who move about among you.” Sunan Abi Dawud, al-Tirmidhi, and al-Nasa’i

This hadith establishes that cats are ordinarily considered pure and may live among people.

The Prophet ﷺ also warned against mistreating cats. He described a woman who was punished because she confined a cat without feeding it or allowing it to find food.

“A woman was punished because of a cat which she confined until it died. She neither gave it food nor water, nor released it to eat from the creatures of the earth.” Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

These narrations establish that keeping cats is permissible, but caring for them properly is an obligation.

The question of purchasing a cat is a separate matter concerning the rules of commercial transactions.

3. The Shafi’i Position: Imam al-Nawawi

Imam al-Nawawi explicitly discusses this hadith in Sharh Sahih Muslim and distinguishes between domesticated cats that provide a lawful benefit and cats that cannot reasonably be kept or benefited from.

He states:

فإن كان مما ينفع وباعه صح البيع وكان ثمنه حلالا

Meaning:

“If the cat is one from which benefit can be obtained and it is sold, the sale is valid and its price is lawful.”

Reference: Imam al-Nawawi, Sharh Sahih Muslim, Book of Musaqah, commentary on Hadith 1569. islamweb.net

Al-Nawawi explains that the majority interpreted the prohibition as referring to cats that provide no lawful benefit or cannot be properly possessed and transferred.

He also discusses the interpretation that the prohibition expresses discouragement rather than absolute unlawfulness, encouraging people to give cats freely rather than insist upon payment.

Importantly, Imam al-Nawawi acknowledges that the hadith is authentic. He does not reject the narration simply because the Shafi’i school permits the sale of domesticated cats.

4. The Hanbali Position: Ibn Qudamah

Ibn Qudamah discusses this issue in al-Mughni and records the permissibility of selling cats.

He states:

وأما الهر فقال الخرقي يجوز بيعها وبه قال ابن عباس والحسن وابن سيرين والحكم وحماد والثوري ومالك والشافعي وإسحاق وأصحاب الرأي

Meaning:

“Regarding cats, al-Khiraqi said that selling them is permissible. This was also the position of Ibn Abbas, al-Hasan, Ibn Sirin, al-Hakam, Hammad, al-Thawri, Malik, al-Shafi’i, Ishaq, and the scholars of personal reasoning.”

Reference: Ibn Qudamah, al-Mughni, Book of Sales, discussion of selling cats and other beneficial animals, vol. 4, p. 175 in one edition. islamweb.net

Ibn Qudamah also mentions a narration from Imam Ahmad expressing dislike for the price of cats.

This demonstrates that there was disagreement even within the Hanbali tradition.

The reasoning supporting permissibility is that a domesticated cat is a lawful animal to own, provides a recognized benefit, and may therefore be exchanged through a valid sale.

5. The Opinion Prohibiting the Sale of Cats

A number of early scholars, including Abu Hurayrah, Tawus, Mujahid, and Jabir ibn Zayd, were reported to have disliked or prohibited selling cats.

Ibn Hazm also defended the prohibition in al-Muhalla, relying upon the apparent meaning of the hadith.

Their reasoning is that the Prophet’s prohibition should be understood according to its general wording unless there is sufficient evidence restricting it.

This is a recognized scholarly position and should not be dismissed.

Nevertheless, the majority of jurists distinguished between domesticated cats that may lawfully be owned and benefited from and cats that do not satisfy the normal conditions of a valid sale.

6. Relevant Usul Principles

First Principle: The Original Ruling of Transactions Is Permissibility

الأصل في المعاملات الإباحة

“The original ruling concerning transactions is permissibility.”

Allah says:

“And Allah has permitted trade and forbidden interest.” Quran 2:275

The majority considered the sale of domesticated cats permissible because they are lawful to possess and provide a recognized benefit.

However, this general principle does not override an authentic prohibition. Rather, the jurists interpreted the hadith concerning cats in light of the relevant conditions of sale and other legal evidence.

Second Principle: Reconciling the Evidence

الجمع بين الأدلة أولى من إهمال بعضها

“Reconciling the evidence is preferable to disregarding some of it.”

The majority did not ignore the hadith prohibiting the price of cats. Instead, they interpreted it as applying to particular circumstances or as indicating discouragement rather than an absolute prohibition.

This allowed them to recognize both the authentic narration and the general permissibility of selling beneficial, domesticated animals.

7. Applying This Ruling to Buying a Pet Cat

If you wish to purchase a domesticated cat from a responsible owner, breeder, or animal shelter, you may do so according to the majority opinion.

There is no requirement to avoid purchasing a cat simply because the seller requests payment.

However, adopting a cat or receiving one as a gift is also a good option, particularly when it helps provide a home for an animal in need.

If someone prefers to follow the stricter scholarly opinion prohibiting cat sales, they may seek adoption or a genuine gift instead.

The important requirement, regardless of how the cat is acquired, is to provide proper care and avoid neglect or mistreatment.

Final Ruling

Yes, there is an authentic hadith in Sahih Muslim concerning the prohibition of receiving payment for cats.

However, the majority of scholars, including the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, and the relied-upon Hanbali positions, permit buying and selling domesticated cats that provide a lawful benefit.

Imam al-Nawawi and Ibn Qudamah explicitly discuss the hadith and explain the basis for permitting such transactions.

A minority of scholars maintained that selling cats is prohibited based on the apparent wording of the hadith.

The stronger practical ruling is that purchasing a domesticated cat as a pet is permissible according to the majority of classical jurists. The buyer and seller are not sinful for following this recognized position.

Giving or adopting a cat without payment remains a commendable alternative, but it is not obligatory according to the majority.

And Allah knows best.


Answered by:
Dr. Mahmoud A. Omar
Islamic Jurist and Mufti
Al-Azhar Fatwa Council Member

Methodology:
This fatwa is based on the Qur’an, the Sunnah, and the established principles of Islamic jurisprudence (Usool), with consideration of contemporary circumstances.