Is It Permissible to Perform Jumu’ah Prayer at a Ski Hill in Edmonton?Question

Is It Permissible to Perform Jumu’ah Prayer at a Ski Hill in Edmonton?

Question

Assalamu alaykum,

Is it permissible to organize a skiing activity on Friday at a ski hill within the Edmonton area and have someone deliver the khutbah and lead Jumu’ah prayer at the location instead of attending a mosque?

If permissible, how many worshippers are required for the prayer to be valid?

Answer

Alhamdulillah, wassalatu wassalamu ala rasulillah, wa ala alihi wa sahbihi ajmain.

Yes, it is permissible to organize a skiing activity on Friday and perform Jumu’ah at a ski hill within Edmonton, provided the established conditions of Jumu’ah are fulfilled.

The Sharia does not universally require Jumu’ah to be performed inside a mosque. The jurists distinguish between the requirement of an established settlement and the requirement of a particular building.

In this case, the ski hill is understood to be within Edmonton’s inhabited urban area, rather than an isolated destination outside the city. This distinction is important because the classical jurists permitted Jumu’ah to be performed in locations other than a mosque under their respective conditions.

The principal questions are therefore whether the location qualifies as part of the city, whether the congregation meets the required number, and whether the khutbah and prayer are conducted correctly.

1. The Shari Basis for Performing Jumu’ah Outside a Mosque

Allah says:

“O you who believe, when the call is made for prayer on Friday, proceed to the remembrance of Allah and leave trade.” Quran 62:9

The verse establishes the obligation of Jumu’ah without specifying that the prayer must take place inside a mosque building.

The jurists subsequently discussed the conditions of the location, the congregation, and the khutbah.

2. The Shafi’i Position: Imam al-Nawawi

Imam al-Nawawi discusses the location of Jumu’ah in al-Majmu’ Sharh al-Muhadhdhab, explaining the Shafi’i requirement that it be established within an inhabited settlement.

He transmits the following statement:

ولا تصح الجمعة إلا في أبنية مجتمعة يستوطنها من تنعقد بهم الجمعة

Meaning:

“Jumu’ah is not valid except in connected buildings inhabited by those through whom Jumu’ah can be established.”

He further explains that the requirement applies to settled towns and villages, with the customary understanding of connected buildings determining the settlement’s boundaries.

The significance of this discussion is that the Shafi’i school emphasizes the established residential character of the location, not simply the presence of a building called a mosque..

Accordingly, a ski facility situated within Edmonton’s built-up urban area is distinguishable from a temporary campsite in the wilderness. Nevertheless, under the strict Shafi’i position, an exposed outdoor slope must still satisfy the school’s location requirements, and the qualifying congregation must consist of forty adult male residents.

3. The Hanbali Position: Ibn Qudamah

Ibn Qudamah states explicitly in al-Mughni:

ولا يشترط لصحة الجمعة إقامتها في البنيان ويجوز إقامتها فيما قاربه من الصحراء

Meaning:

“It is not a condition for the validity of Jumu’ah that it be performed within buildings. It is permissible to establish it in open land close to them.”

He then adds:

وبهذا قال أبو حنيفة

“Abu Hanifah also held this position.”

Ibn Qudamah supports this ruling by discussing the early establishment of Jumu’ah and drawing an analogy with the outdoor prayer ground used for Eid. عبد الله بن قدامة

This is particularly relevant to the skiing question.

According to this Hanbali position, Jumu’ah may be performed outdoors, including on open land adjoining an established city.

Therefore, a ski hill within Edmonton’s urban area can satisfy the location requirement even if the prayer is conducted outdoors rather than inside a mosque.

The other conditions of Jumu’ah, including the required congregation, must still be fulfilled.

4. The Hanafi Position: Al-Kasani

Imam al-Kasani explains in Bada’i al-Sana’i that the Hanafi school requires Jumu’ah to be established within a city or its recognized adjoining areas.

He states:

فلا تجب الجمعة إلا على أهل المصر ومن كان ساكنا في توابعه

Meaning:

“Jumu’ah is obligatory upon the inhabitants of the city and those residing in its adjoining areas.”

He further states:

ولا يصح أداء الجمعة إلا في المصر وتوابعه

“Jumu’ah is not valid except in the city and its adjoining areas.” فصل بيان شرائط الجمعة- الجزء رقم1

The expression tawabi’ al-misr refers to places legally regarded as belonging to the city.

This is relevant to Edmonton because a ski hill within its urban area may fall within the city or its recognized adjoining facilities.

The Hanafi school does not require a mosque building for Jumu’ah. However, it also requires public accessibility and has classical conditions concerning authorization to establish the prayer.

Therefore, an outdoor Jumu’ah organized at an Edmonton ski hill has a recognized basis in Hanafi jurisprudence, provided these additional conditions are observed.

5. The Maliki Position

The Maliki school adopts a more restrictive position concerning the place of Jumu’ah.

In Manh al-Jalil Sharh Mukhtasar Khalil, the requirement is expressed as:

وشرط صحة الجمعة وقوعها بجامع مبني بناء معتادا لأهل البلد

Meaning:

“A condition for the validity of Jumu’ah is that it be performed in a congregational mosque constructed according to the customary buildings of the locality.” Islam Web

Therefore, the Maliki school generally requires a qualifying congregational mosque and would not ordinarily consider an outdoor Jumu’ah on a ski slope valid merely because the slope is within Edmonton.

This remains a recognized difference between the schools.

6. How Many Worshippers Are Required?

The jurists also differ regarding the minimum congregation.

  • Hanafi: Four adult Muslim men, including the imam, according to Abu Hanifah and Muhammad al-Shaybani. Abu Yusuf permits three, including the imam.
  • Maliki: Twelve qualifying resident men in addition to the imam.
  • Shafi’i: Forty qualifying adult male residents, including the imam.
  • Hanbali: Forty qualifying adult male residents, including the imam, according to the relied-upon position, although other opinions permit smaller congregations.

Some scholars, including Ibn Taymiyyah, supported the validity of Jumu’ah with a smaller congregation. Other scholars have argued that three people, including the imam, are sufficient.

There is no explicit authentic hadith establishing forty as an undisputed universal minimum for every valid Jumu’ah. The disagreement arises from the jurists’ interpretation of the relevant evidence and early practice.

For an organized Friday skiing activity, the opinion permitting a smaller congregation may be followed where its other conditions are fulfilled, particularly when arranging forty qualifying worshippers is difficult.

However, one should not combine the minimum number from one school with other conditions from another without considering whether the resulting Jumu’ah is valid under a coherent recognized scholarly position.

7. Is It Permissible to Schedule Skiing on Friday?

There is no prohibition against recreational activities on Friday in themselves.

Allah says:

“And when the prayer has been concluded, disperse through the land and seek the bounty of Allah.” Quran 62:10

The obligation is to preserve Jumu’ah, not to prohibit lawful recreation throughout Friday.

Accordingly, Muslims may arrange skiing, hiking, educational outings, or other permissible activities on Friday, provided they do not neglect an obligatory prayer.

If the group establishes a valid Jumu’ah at the ski hill, there is no inherent prohibition against combining the recreational activity with the Friday prayer.

8. Relevant Usul Principles

الأصل في العبادات التوقيف

“The original basis of acts of worship is adherence to what has been prescribed.”

Jumu’ah must satisfy its established legal conditions. However, conditions should not be added without adequate evidence.

Another relevant principle is:

العرف محكم

“Custom is authoritative in determining matters where the Sharia refers to customary understanding.”

This principle is relevant when identifying the boundaries of an established city and its adjoining areas.

Whether a recreational facility forms part of Edmonton’s inhabited urban area is a matter of tahqiq al-manat, applying the legal conditions to the actual geographical circumstances.

A third principle is:

لا ينكر المختلف فيه وإنما ينكر المجمع عليه

“Matters subject to recognized scholarly disagreement are not condemned in the same manner as matters prohibited by consensus.”

This does not mean that every opinion is automatically valid. Rather, when a congregation follows a sound, recognized scholarly position with its conditions, the existence of another legitimate opinion should be acknowledged.

Final Ruling

It is permissible to organize a Friday skiing activity at a ski hill within Edmonton and establish Jumu’ah there, provided the conditions of a recognized scholarly position are fulfilled.

The Hanbali school, as explicitly stated by Ibn Qudamah, permits Jumu’ah in open land adjoining an established settlement. The Hanafi school likewise recognizes Jumu’ah within the city and its adjoining areas without requiring a mosque building.

The Shafi’i school permits Jumu’ah outside a mosque but maintains stricter requirements concerning the settled location and congregation. The Maliki school generally requires a qualifying congregational mosque.

Therefore, an outdoor Jumu’ah at an Edmonton ski hill can be valid under the Hanafi or Hanbali approach, assuming the facility is within or sufficiently adjoining the settled urban area, the congregation satisfies the applicable numerical and residency requirements, the khutbah is properly delivered, and the prayer is established in a manner consistent with the school’s other conditions.

For a small organized group, a recognized scholarly opinion permitting a smaller congregation may be considered, but the number alone does not establish validity. The organizers should also ensure that the prayer is not an unjustifiably restricted private gathering and that establishing a separate Jumu’ah is acceptable under the opinion being followed.

There is no requirement to cancel the skiing activity simply because it takes place on Friday. The essential requirement is that Jumu’ah be performed validly and not neglected.

And Allah knows best.


Answered by:
Dr. Mahmoud A. Omar
Islamic Jurist and Mufti
Al-Azhar Fatwa Council Member

Methodology:
This fatwa is based on the Qur’an, the Sunnah, and the established principles of Islamic jurisprudence (Usool), with consideration of contemporary circumstances.